top of page
Search

When the Evidence Disappears: Your Rights in Colorado When Police Fail to Preserve Evidence

Writer: Michael Swink
Michael Swink
Sep 30
9 min read

Introduction

Evidence sometimes goes missing. A squad-car video is overwritten, a breath sample is never retained, a photo array is misplaced, or a biological sample is consumed during testing. When that happens in a Colorado criminal case, defendants often ask a fair question: if the government lost or destroyed something that might have helped me, shouldn't the case be thrown out? The answer is sometimes yes, but more often it depends on what the evidence was, how clearly it could have helped the defense, whether the defense can prove the point another way, and, in some situations, whether the police acted in bad faith.

This post explains the constitutional rules that govern the government's duty to preserve evidence, how Colorado courts apply those rules, what remedies are available when evidence is lost, the practical procedures that come into play, the arguments prosecutors typically raise, and the special statutory rules that protect DNA evidence.

The Starting Point: The Duty to Disclose Favorable Evidence

The constitutional story begins with disclosure, not preservation. Under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, the prosecution must disclose to a criminal defendant evidence in its possession that is favorable and material to guilt or punishment. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984) That duty applies even when the defense never specifically asks for the evidence, because the prosecution must turn over exculpatory evidence that would raise a reasonable doubt about guilt. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984)

Colorado's own criminal discovery rule reinforces this obligation. The prosecuting attorney must disclose to the defense any material or information within the prosecution's possession or control that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or reduce the punishment. Colo. Crim. P. 16

From Disclosing Evidence to Preserving It: The Trombetta Test

Disclosing evidence the government still has is one thing; a separate question is whether the Constitution requires the government to preserve evidence in the first place. The U.S. Supreme Court addressed that question in a case involving breath samples in drunk-driving prosecutions, holding that the Due Process Clause does not require law enforcement to preserve breath samples in order to admit breath-test results at trial. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984)

In reaching that result, the Court announced the test that still governs. Whatever duty the Constitution imposes to preserve evidence is limited to evidence that might be expected to play a significant role in the suspect's defense, and to meet that standard the evidence must both possess an exculpatory value that was apparent before it was destroyed and be of such a nature that the defendant would be unable to obtain comparable evidence by other reasonably available means. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984)

The Court also emphasized that the officers in that case had acted in good faith and in accord with their normal practice, with no effort to suppress exculpatory evidence, and it noted that defendants had other ways to challenge the test results, such as inspecting the machine and its calibration records and cross-examining the operator. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984)

The Critical Distinction: “Material Exculpatory” Versus “Potentially Useful” Evidence

Four years later, the Supreme Court drew a line that is often decisive. When the State fails to disclose material exculpatory evidence, the good or bad faith of the State is irrelevant; a due process violation occurs regardless of intent. Ariz. v. Youngblood, 488 U.S. 51 (1988) But the Court held that a different rule applies when the State fails to preserve evidence that could merely have been subjected to testing, the results of which might have exonerated the defendant — so-called potentially useful evidence. Ariz. v. Youngblood, 488 U.S. 51 (1988)

For that category, the Court declined to impose on the police an undifferentiated and absolute duty to retain all material that might have conceivable evidentiary significance. Ariz. v. Youngblood, 488 U.S. 51 (1988) As Colorado courts have summarized the rule, unless a defendant can show bad faith on the part of the police, the failure to preserve potentially useful evidence does not constitute a denial of due process. People v. Abdu, 215 P.3d 1265 (2009)

In short, the path to relief depends on the nature of the lost evidence. If its exculpatory value was apparent before it was lost and cannot be replaced, the defendant need not prove bad faith. If the evidence was only potentially useful, the defendant generally must prove the police acted in bad faith.

How Colorado Applies These Rules

The Colorado Supreme Court adopted the federal materiality analysis and has expressly declined to read the Colorado Constitution as providing broader protection than federal law in this area. People v. Wartena, 156 P.3d 469 (2007)

Colorado courts apply a three-part test for a due process violation based on failure to preserve exculpatory evidence. The defendant must establish each of the following elements:

All three parts of the test must be established before a court will find a due process violation. People v. Enriquez, 763 P.2d 1033 (1988) Colorado courts have continued to apply this same three-part framework in later cases. People v. Braunthal, 31 P.3d 167 (2001)

Two practical points follow from how courts apply these elements. First, whether substitute evidence is truly “comparable” is a fact-specific question; in one case the Colorado Supreme Court declined to hold as a matter of law that photographs were comparable to the evidence they depicted, leaving that determination to the finder of fact. People v. Enriquez, 763 P.2d 1033 (1988) Second, for evidence that is only potentially useful rather than apparently exculpatory, Colorado follows the federal rule that relief generally requires a showing of bad faith, and courts have found no due process bar to good-faith testing that consumes or destroys a sample. People v. Wartena, 156 P.3d 469 (2007)

Remedies When Evidence Is Lost or Destroyed

Finding a due process violation is only the first step. The remedy is a separate question, and Colorado courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy that fits the harm. Even where the character of the evidence, not the good or bad faith of the police, determines whether a violation occurred, the degree of governmental culpability is an appropriate consideration in choosing the sanction. People v. Sams, 685 P.2d 157 (1984)

Dismissal is the most drastic remedy and is reserved for situations where no other sanction would achieve the proper result. People v. Sams, 685 P.2d 157 (1984) In fashioning a sanction, a court should strive to restore, as nearly as possible, the level playing field that existed before the violation, and dismissal is required only when that goal cannot otherwise be achieved. People v. District Court, City & County of Denver, 808 P.2d 831 (1991)

The remedies a court may consider therefore range along a spectrum, including:

Colorado courts apply the same restraint to discovery sanctions generally. The trial court must impose the least severe sanction that will ensure full compliance with its discovery orders, and courts should generally avoid excluding evidence as a sanction because exclusion is a drastic remedy that can affect the outcome of trial and hinder the search for truth. People v. Whittington, 2024 CO 65 (2024)

Practical and Procedural Considerations

Colorado's criminal discovery rule drives much of the practical work. The rule is self-executing: the prosecution must disclose police, arrest, and crime reports, witness statements, expert reports, scientific test results, and tangible objects held as evidence, generally as soon as practicable but no later than twenty-one days after the defendant's first appearance for certain core materials. Colo. Crim. P. 16

The rule also imposes a continuing duty to disclose newly discovered material, and it authorizes the court to order whatever sanction it deems just when a party fails to comply. Colo. Crim. P. 16

Colorado law separately allows the defense to inspect physical evidence. Upon request by either party, and subject to constitutional limitations, a court may issue orders governing the viewing of evidence based on the circumstances of the case, and nothing in that provision limits the defense's ability to request its own testing. C.R.S. 16-9-801

When evidence is unavailable, a structured review helps counsel and the court assess the problem. Practice guidance suggests determining what evidence existed and who controlled it, when and how it became unavailable, whether its value was apparently exculpatory or merely potentially useful, whether comparable evidence remains available, who was responsible for the loss, and what remedy may be warranted. Municipal Court Case Management and Trial Readiness Checklist That same guidance frames the constitutional analysis around the apparent-exculpatory-value, comparable-evidence, and bad-faith inquiries drawn from the governing Supreme Court decisions. Municipal Court Case Management and Trial Readiness Checklist

Special Rules for DNA Evidence

Colorado has enacted statutory preservation duties for biological evidence that go beyond the general constitutional baseline. A law enforcement agency that collects DNA evidence while investigating a felony that does not result in charges must preserve that evidence for the length of the statute of limitations for the crime investigated, and when an investigation results in a listed conviction, the agency must preserve the DNA evidence for the life of the convicted defendant. C.R.S. 18-1-1103

A companion statute governs how that evidence must be kept. The agency must preserve the evidence in an amount and manner sufficient to develop a DNA profile using the best scientific practices at the time of collection, and the preserved evidence should, whenever possible, include a sample sufficient to allow independent testing by the defendant. C.R.S. 18-1-1104

The same statute builds in accountability. If an agency cannot produce DNA evidence that was subject to preservation, its chief evidence custodian must provide a sworn affidavit describing the efforts made to locate it, and the court must then determine whether the disposal of the evidence violated the defendant's due process rights and, if so, order an appropriate remedy. C.R.S. 18-1-1104

What the Prosecution Will Argue

Defendants should anticipate several recurring responses. Prosecutors typically argue that the lost item was only potentially useful, not apparently exculpatory, so that relief requires proof of bad faith that the defendant cannot supply. Ariz. v. Youngblood, 488 U.S. 51 (1988)

They also argue that the loss reflected good faith and routine practice rather than any effort to suppress evidence, which the Supreme Court treated as significant in rejecting a preservation claim. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984) And they frequently contend that the defense can make its point through comparable evidence — machine records, witnesses, photographs, or cross-examination — which defeats the third element of the Colorado test. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479 (1984)

Finally, even where a violation is shown, the prosecution will urge a remedy short of dismissal, relying on the principle that dismissal is a drastic remedy reserved for cases in which no lesser sanction will restore fairness. People v. Sams, 685 P.2d 157 (1984); People v. District Court, City & County of Denver, 808 P.2d 831 (1991)

Key Takeaways

A Note About This Post

This article provides general legal information about Colorado law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Evidence-preservation questions are highly fact-specific, deadlines are short, and outcomes turn on the particular record. Anyone facing a criminal charge involving lost or destroyed evidence should consult a licensed Colorado attorney about their individual situation.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page