Appealing a Criminal Conviction in Colorado: What Defendants Should Know
A plain-language guide to how criminal appeals work in Colorado — from the right to appeal and filing deadlines to counsel, the record, the limits on what a court will review, and how an appeal differs from certiorari and postconviction relief.
The Right to Appeal After a Conviction
In Colorado, a criminal case does not necessarily end when a trial court enters a conviction. By statute, every person convicted of an offense under the laws of this state has the right to appeal in order to review the proceedings that resulted in the conviction. C.R.S. 16-12-101
For felony convictions, Colorado courts have described this protection as a statutory direct appeal as of right available to every person convicted of a felony. People v. Ari Misha Liggett, 2018 COA 94M (2018) The procedures that govern how such an appeal proceeds are set by rule of the Colorado Supreme Court. C.R.S. 16-12-101
Where a Colorado Criminal Appeal Goes
Colorado has two kinds of trial courts — county courts and district courts — and each provides a different route to appellate review. People v. Maser, 2012 CO 41 (2012)
Convictions in District Court
A conviction entered in the district court is directly appealable to the Colorado Court of Appeals, and after that initial appeal either party may ask the Colorado Supreme Court for certiorari review. People v. Maser, 2012 CO 41 (2012)
Convictions in County Court
A conviction entered in the county court is, as a matter of statutory right, automatically appealable to the district court for the judicial district in which the county is located. People v. Maser, 2012 CO 41 (2012) Appeals from final county court judgments go to that district court and are based on the record made in the county court. C.R.S. 13-6-310
These county court appeals follow a simplified procedure: the defendant must, within 35 days after the county court enters judgment or denies post-trial motions (whichever is later), file a notice of appeal in the county court, pay any required costs, serve the appellee, and file the notice of appeal in the district court with the docket fee. Colo. Crim. P. 37
On such an appeal, the district court reviews the case on the record and may affirm, reverse, remand, or modify the judgment, and in its discretion may remand for a new trial or direct that the case be tried anew before the district court. C.R.S. 13-6-310
Convictions in Municipal Court
A defendant may appeal from a judgment of a municipal court that is not a qualified municipal court of record to the county court, where the case is tried anew. C.R.S. 13-10-116 Appeals from a qualified municipal court of record instead go to the district court and follow the same practice used for misdemeanor appeals from the county court. C.R.S. 13-10-116
Deadlines Matter: Filing the Notice of Appeal
An appeal as of right from a lower court is taken by filing a notice of appeal with the clerk of the appellate court within the time allowed, and once it is filed the appellate court has exclusive jurisdiction over the appeal. C.A.R. 3
In criminal cases, the defendant's notice of appeal generally must be filed in the appellate court, with an advisory copy served on the lower court, within 49 days after entry of the judgment or order being appealed. C.A.R. 4
Certain post-trial motions can reset that clock. If the defendant files a timely motion in arrest of judgment, for judgment of acquittal, or for a new trial on a ground other than newly discovered evidence, the appeal from a judgment of conviction must be taken within 49 days after entry of an order denying the motion. C.A.R. 4 A motion for a new trial based on newly discovered evidence similarly extends the time if it is made within 14 days after entry of the judgment. C.A.R. 4
Upon a showing of excusable neglect, the appellate court may extend the time to file a criminal notice of appeal for a period not to exceed 35 days beyond the time otherwise prescribed. C.A.R. 4
County court criminal appeals run on a shorter, separate schedule: the notice of appeal must be filed within 35 days after the county court enters judgment or denies post-trial motions, whichever is later. Colo. Crim. P. 37
Because missing a filing deadline can forfeit the ability to be heard, the specific deadline that applies in a given case should be confirmed carefully against the governing rules.
Counsel and the Record on Appeal
When a judgment of conviction is entered after a trial, the court must, after passing sentence, inform the defendant of the right to seek review of the conviction and sentence and of the time limits for filing a notice of appeal. Colo. Crim. P. 32 At that point the court must determine whether the defendant is indigent and, if so, advise the defendant of the right to appointed counsel on review and the right to obtain a record on appeal without paying costs. Colo. Crim. P. 32
Where a conviction is entered after a guilty plea or a plea of nolo contendere, the court must inform the defendant that in certain circumstances there may be a right to appellate review of the sentence and of the applicable time limits. Colo. Crim. P. 32
Colorado's direct felony appeal includes the right to counsel and the right to the effective assistance of appellate counsel. People v. Ari Misha Liggett, 2018 COA 94M (2018) This reflects the federal constitutional principle that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees a criminal defendant the effective assistance of counsel on a first appeal as of right, so that the appeal is not reduced to a meaningless ritual. Evitts v. Lucey, 469 U.S. 387 (1985)
The appeal is decided on a defined record. The record on appeal consists of the documents filed in the trial court as of the date the notice of appeal is filed, together with the transcripts the parties designate or, in limited circumstances such as when a transcript is unavailable, a certified statement of the evidence or proceedings. C.A.R. 10
An appellant who intends to rely on transcripts must designate them, filing the designation with the trial court and an advisory copy with the appellate court within 7 days of filing the notice of appeal, and must include transcripts of all proceedings necessary to decide the issues raised. C.A.R. 10
What an Appellate Court Will — and Will Not — Review
A direct appeal is not a retrial, and the issues a court will consider are limited. A defendant may forfeit the right to correct a constitutional error by failing to make an adequate, contemporaneous objection in the trial court. Martinez v. People, 2015 CO 16 (2015) A general objection does not suffice; a party must object specifically enough to draw the trial court's attention to the asserted error. Martinez v. People, 2015 CO 16 (2015)
When a party raises a new argument for the first time on appeal, the reviewing court applies the plain error standard. Martinez v. People, 2015 CO 16 (2015) Colorado's rules provide that plain errors or defects affecting substantial rights may be noticed even though they were not brought to the trial court's attention, while errors that do not affect substantial rights are disregarded as harmless. Colo. Crim. P. 52
Under that standard, a court may review an unpreserved error if there is an error, that is plain, and that affects the defendant's substantial rights. People v. Crabtree., 2024 CO 40M (2024) An error is plain only if it is obvious — so clear-cut that a trial judge should have been able to avoid it without an objection — which generally means it must contravene a clear statutory command, a well-settled legal principle, or established Colorado case law. People v. Crabtree., 2024 CO 40M (2024)
Colorado's plain error standard also differs from the federal one in an important way: if a Colorado appellate court concludes that an unpreserved error was obvious and affected the defendant's substantial rights, relief is mandatory rather than discretionary. People v. Crabtree., 2024 CO 40M (2024) Colorado's standard also omits the fourth federal prong, which asks whether an error seriously affects the fairness, integrity, or public reputation of judicial proceedings. People v. Crabtree., 2024 CO 40M (2024)
Appealing a Sentence
Beyond challenging the conviction itself, a person sentenced for a felony generally has the right to one appellate review of the propriety of the sentence, considering the nature of the offense, the character of the offender, the public interest, and the manner in which the sentence was imposed, including the sufficiency and accuracy of the information on which it was based. C.R.S. 18-1-409
An important exception applies to negotiated sentences: if the sentence falls within a range the parties agreed upon in a plea agreement, the defendant has no right to appellate review of the sentence's propriety. C.R.S. 18-1-409 The appellate rules state the same limitation for sentences imposed within a plea-agreement range. C.A.R. 4
To obtain sentence review, a written notice stating the grounds must be filed in the trial court within 49 days from the date the sentence is imposed. C.R.S. 18-1-409
Possible Outcomes of an Appeal
The relief available depends on the type of review. On county court appeals, the district court may affirm, reverse, remand, or modify the judgment, and may in its discretion remand for a new trial or order a trial anew in the district court. C.R.S. 13-6-310
On felony sentence review, the reviewing court may affirm the sentence, substitute any penalty that was open to the sentencing court other than probation or conditional release, or remand for further proceedings and resentencing. C.R.S. 18-1-409 A sentence greater than the one originally imposed may be given only if additional aggravating matters not known at the original sentencing are presented, and the court must identify those additional facts. C.R.S. 18-1-409
How an Appeal Differs from Certiorari and Postconviction Relief
Certiorari Review
A direct appeal as of right is different from discretionary review on certiorari. Review in the Colorado Supreme Court on a writ of certiorari is a matter of sound judicial discretion and will be granted only when there are special and important reasons. C.A.R. 49
The rule lists illustrative reasons that may warrant certiorari, such as when the court of appeals has decided a question of substance in a way probably not in accord with Supreme Court decisions, or when one division of the court of appeals has issued a decision conflicting with another division. C.A.R. 49
For cases that begin in county court, a further appeal to the Colorado Supreme Court from the district court's determination may be made only on a writ of certiorari issued in the Supreme Court's discretion. C.R.S. 13-6-310
Postconviction Relief
Postconviction relief is also distinct from a direct appeal. If a court finds that a defendant is entitled to postconviction relief, it may enter orders to restore a violated right — for example, vacating the judgment, imposing a new sentence, granting a new trial, or discharging the defendant. Colo. Crim. P. 35
Postconviction review is limited by what came before. A court must deny a claim that was already raised and resolved in a prior appeal or postconviction proceeding, and generally must deny a claim that could have been presented in an earlier appeal or proceeding, subject to narrow exceptions such as claims based on newly discoverable evidence or a new, retroactively applied rule of constitutional law. Colo. Crim. P. 35
Relatedly, at sentencing the trial court must also inform a defendant of the right to seek a postconviction reduction of sentence in the trial court under Rule 35(b). Colo. Crim. P. 32
A Note on Using This Guide
This article is general information about Colorado criminal appeals and is not legal advice. The deadlines that apply and the issues available for review depend on the specific facts and procedural history of each case, including the court involved, the nature of the charges, whether issues were preserved, and whether a plea agreement was entered. Anyone considering an appeal should promptly consult a qualified attorney about the rules and time limits that govern their particular situation.



Comments